Gary Webb and Media
Manipulation
Many Americans still
count on the mainstream media to define reality for them, but too often the MSM
spins false narratives that protect the powerful and diminish democracy, as
happened in the long-running denial of cocaine trafficking by President
Reagan’s beloved Nicaraguan Contra rebels, writes Beverly Bandler.
By Beverly Bandler
November 03, 2014 "ICH" - "Consortium News" - The sad tale of the
mainstream U.S. media’s destruction of journalist Gary Webb for reviving the
Contra-cocaine scandal in the 1990s – a story recounted in the movie “Kill the
Messenger” – is important not only because of Webb’s tragic demise but because
the case goes to the central question of whether the American people are
getting information and facts to which we are entitled in a free society, or
whether we are being manipulated with half-truths, propaganda and straight-out
lies.
What is ironic about the recent patronizing anti-Webb commentary by the
Washington Post’s Jeff Leen – claiming that “an extraordinary claim requires
extraordinary proof” – is that the Post was a prime salesman for the Iraq War
in 2002 and 2003. And just what “proof” did the Post require for the
“extraordinary claim” about Iraq hiding stockpiles of WMD, the chief selling
point to the American people? Apparently nothing more than “jingoism,” the
beating of war drums and empty assurances from the Bush administration’s
neocons.
As journalist Michael
Massing pointed out in February 2004 – after the U.S. invasion force failed to
find the promised stockpiles – “‘Iraq’s Arsenal Was Only on Paper,’ declared a
recent headline in The Washington Post.”
But Leen’s commentary in
response to “Kill the Messenger” was just the latest example of the mainstream
press covering its own tracks for its failure to pursue the Contra-cocaine
scandal and for its complicity in destroying Gary Webb.
It’s now clear that the
CIA has long been trying to fend off the reality of the Contra-cocaine scandal,
often with the help of what a newly released CIA report described as its
“productive relations with journalists.”
Americans need to know
about such “dark alliances,” the title that Webb gave his original series at
the San Jose Mercury News and later his book. This posting is about two such “dark
alliances”: 1) The Contra-cocaine scandal that surfaced in 1985 when then
Associated Press colleagues Robert Parry and Brian Barger first broke the news.
2) The concerted effort by U.S. major news media — specifically, the New
York Times, Los Angeles Times and Washington Post – to not only
disparage the scandal but also discredit investigative reporter Gary Webb who,
in 1996, revived the story by explaining the Contra cocaine’s impact on U.S.
cities in the 1980s.
‘Just Say No’
Webb’s revelations, of
course, flew in the face of the conventional wisdom that President Ronald
Reagan was a stern enemy of drugs and a fierce threat to drug traffickers. On
Oct. 27, 1986, Reagan budgeted $1.7 billion for the drug war and federalized
Rockefeller law-style mandatory-minimum sentences. The message was: “Just say
no.”
It also turned out that
the CIA’s “productive relations with journalists” proved so strong that it
didn’t even seem to matter when official government investigations confirmed
key facts about the Contra-cocaine scandal.
For instance, Sen. John
Kerry chaired a 2 ½-year investigation of the Senate Subcommittee on Terrorism,
Narcotics, and International Operations that reported in 1989: “It is clear
that individuals who provided support for the Contras were involved in drug
trafficking … and elements of the Contras themselves knowingly received
financial and material assistance from drug traffickers.”
Commenting on Kerry’s
investigation and the major U.S. media’s response, journalism professor Jeff
Cohen wrote: ”Contra drug dealing was tolerated in the U.S. frenzy to overthrow
Nicaragua’s leftwing Sandinista government. Kerry’s work was ignored or
attacked in big media — Newsweek labeled him a ‘randy conspiracy buff.’
”
With Kerry and his
investigation dismissed as irrelevant by the big newspapers, the scandal
remained largely suppressed for the next seven years until Webb revived it in
1996.
Webb (1955-2004) was an
investigative journalist whose awards included a Pulitzer in 1990, as part of a
team at the San Jose Mercury News, and at least four other major prizes for his solo work. Webb
tried to reveal the impact that some of the cocaine that came through the
Nicaraguan Contra pipeline had on American cities, saying:
“It’s not a situation
where the government or the CIA sat down and said okay, let’s invent crack and
sell it in black neighborhoods and let’s decimate black America. It was a
situation where we need money for a covert operation. The quickest way to raise
it is to sell cocaine and you guys go sell it somewhere. We don’t want to know
anything about it. And you had this bad luck of them doing it right around the time
people were figuring out how to make crack.”
A Sad But True Tale
“This, sadly, is a true
story,” Webb wrote in his 1999 book, Dark Alliance. It is a story now
told in the Hollywood film, “Kill the Messenger,” based on the book of the same
name by Nick Schou and Webb’s Dark Alliance.
The story begins with
Webb’s 1996 series “Dark Alliance” in California’s San Jose Mercury
News. Webb investigated and told how for a better part of a decade, in a
“wildly successful conspiracy,” a San Francisco Bay area drug ring sold tons of
cocaine to Los Angeles street gangs and funneled millions of dollars in drug
profits from those sales to the CIA-backed Nicaraguan Contras.
For his investigation,
Webb drew from newly declassified documents, newly released undercover DEA
audio and videotapes, federal court testimony, and interviews, and he
demonstrated how the federal government knowingly allowed massive amounts of
drugs and money to change hands at the expense of U.S. communities.
The “Dark Alliance” Mercury
News series “might have vanished without a trace had the paper not chosen
this story to create a splash for its website, complete with graphics and links
to original source documents,” wrote Dan Simon, editor of Webb’s book and
publisher of Seven Stories Press.
“It became, arguably,
the first big Internet news story, with as many as 1.3 million hits on a single
day. Talk radio picked it up off the Internet, and citizens’ groups and media
watchdogs soon followed. The CIA launched its own internal investigation. Gary’s
star had never shone more brightly…
“The mainstream print
media was ominously silent until October and November 1996,” Simon continued,
“when The New York Times, The Washington Post, and the Los
Angeles Times all finally picked up the story. But instead of launching
their own investigations into whether the CIA had shielded drug traffickers,
these papers went after Gary’s reporting, although they ‘could not find a
single significant factual error,’ as Gary’s then-editor at The Mercury News,
Jerry Ceppos, would write in an internal memo.
“But after that, the
series was described frequently as ‘discredited.’ Soon the story and Gary
himself were spoiled goods. Gary’s editor switched sides and penned an apologia
distancing the paper from the series. Gary was forced out of his job, even
though the body of evidence supporting Gary’s account was actually growing. Two
years later, the CIA’s internal investigation would prove to be a vindication
of Gary’s work.”
African-American Outrage
There was also an
important social and political dimension to Webb’s revelations. “The
investigative series sparked protests in African-American and congressional
probes,” noted Democracy Now! “It also provoked a fierce reaction from
the media establishment, which denounced the series. The Los Angeles Times
alone assigned 17 reporters to probe Webb’s report and his personal life.
“Recently declassified
CIA files show the agency used a ‘a ground base of already productive relations
with journalists [at other newspapers]‘ to counter what it called ‘a genuine
public relations crisis.’ …
“Following the
controversy, the San Jose Mercury News demoted Webb. He then resigned
and pushed his investigation even further in his book, Dark Alliance: The
CIA, the Contras, and the Crack Cocaine Explosion.
“The CIA’s inspector
general later corroborated Webb’s key findings, but, by then, his career was
wrecked. The newspapers that denounced Webb largely ignored the CIA’s own
report — it was released in 1998 amid the scandal over President Bill Clinton’s
affair with Monica Lewinsky.”
“The second CIA report
not only vindicates me,” wrote Gary Webb to a fellow journalist in July 24,
1998, “but all the other reporters and activists who have been trying to bring
this to the public’s attention for the last 13 years. It also proves that, once
again, the CIA lied to the American public and was assisted in this effort by
our national news media, which denigrated anyone who challenged the official
denials.”
Rep. Maxine Waters,
D-California, an outspoken member of the Congressional Black Caucus, recalled
that “The night that I read [Webb’s] ‘Dark Alliance’ series, I was so alarmed,
that I literally sat straight up in bed, poring over every word. I reflected on
the many meetings I attended throughout South Central Los Angeles during the
1980s, when I constantly asked, ‘Where are all the drugs coming from?’ I asked
myself that night whether it was possible for such a vast amount of drugs to be
smuggled into any district under the noses of the community leaders, police,
sheriff’s department, FBI, DEA and other law enforcement agencies…
“The time I spent
investigating the allegations of the ‘Dark Alliance’ series led me to the
undeniable conclusion that the CIA, DEA, DIA, and FBI knew about drug
trafficking in South Central Los Angeles. They were either part of the
trafficking or turned a blind eye to it, an effort to fund the Contra war and
that the drug money was used by both sides…
“It may take time, but I
am convinced that history is going to record that Gary Webb wrote the truth.
The establishment refused to give Gary Webb the credit that he deserved. They
teamed up in an effort to destroy the story — and very nearly succeeded. … We
will not let this story end until the naysayers and opponents are forced to
apologize for their reckless and irresponsible attacks on Gary Webb.”
A Disgraceful Episode
Charles P. Pierce, a
political writer for Esquire.com, said: “Of all the disgraceful episodes
regarding the press and the Reagan administration, the discrediting of Gary
Webb was probably the worst, given the fact that so much of the elite press was
complicit in what was done to him.”
But Webb’s brave
reporting had a lasting historical impact because it finally forced the Central
Intelligence Agency to conduct a serious investigation of the Contra-cocaine
problem and what the CIA knew about the scandal and what actions the agency
took or didn’t take.
“[CIA Inspector General
Frederick] Hitz completed his investigation in mid-1998 and the second volume
of his two-volume investigation was published on Oct. 8, 1998. In the report,
Hitz identified more than 50 Contras and Contra-related entities implicated in
the drug trade. He also detailed how the Reagan administration had protected
these drug operations and frustrated federal investigations throughout the
1980s,” reported journalist Robert Parry.
Andrew Hehir of
Salon.com wrote: “Here’s the important thing to say about Webb’s big story: In
general terms, and in most of its specifics, it was true. Virtually no
one would deny that today; congressional commissions, internal CIA
investigations and scholarly articles by historians have reached similar
conclusions, shrouded in more lawyerly or diplomatic language.
“You can say that the CIA
was apparently complicit in drug-dealing but not directly involved; you can say
that the agency ‘turned a blind eye’ to evidence that smuggling revenue was
being used to fund the Contras; you can say that ‘the CIA knew or should have
known that some of its allies were accused of being in the drug business,’ in
the exceedingly careful phrasing of New York Times media reporter David
Carr.
“If the tone of Webb’s
reporting was sometimes inflammatory, what he said happened pretty much
happened. Webb never stated or implied that the CIA had deliberately imported
crack cocaine into African-American neighborhoods; that construction or
interpretation came later, from other people.”
Filmmaker Marc Levin
noted at HuffingtonPost, “The idea that the CIA works with drug traffickers and
other criminals and sometimes facilitates their operations and protects them as
assets in return for their help in defeating our enemies (i.e. Communists
during the Cold War and now Islamic fundamentalists) is not ‘an extraordinary
claim.’ It’s a fact.”
See the Movie
I believe each one of us
can do something of value: we can go see the film, “Kill the Messenger,”
encourage others to do so, read and share the references in the “recommended
reading” list below among others and come to our own conclusions.
This issue is not only
about a movie and what it reveals, but it is about what Alternet’s Don
Hazen states has become a basic tenet of American politics: “that corporate
power rules the roost. Nothing significant that will become law in America if
corporate power, profits, global competitive advantage, military might,
national security and privatization are in any significant way threatened.”
DemocracyNow’s Amy
Goodman added: “That’s really what will save us, is when we really know
what’s going on, not filtered through the lens or the microphone of the
corporation.”
In 2004, rejected by his
profession, essentially unemployable, impoverished, divorced, alone, and facing
eviction, the 49-year-old Webb prepared for his own cremation and sent suicide
notes to family members. He was found dead at his Sacramento County, California
home with two gunshot wounds to his head, an apparent suicide.
“Now when I reread the
opening sentence of the ‘Dark Alliance’ series,” writes book editor Dan Simon,
“I realize Gary had found the big story, the one about the betrayal of a people
by its own government. A monumental sadness remains.”
Simon added, “The
alternative media, to its credit, honored Gary. But the community of his
peers in corporate journalism never again embraced him. He could never quite
get over their betrayal. When you are an investigative reporter armed with the
truth, the gun often fires backwards.”
America is not what we
think it is.
Beverly Bandler’s public
affairs career spans some 40 years. Her credentials include serving as
president of the state-level League of Women Voters of the Virgin Islands and
extensive public education efforts in the Washington, D.C. area for 16 years.
She writes from Mexico.
VIDEOS
“Kill the Messenger” Resurrects Gary Webb, Journalist Maligned for
Exposing CIA Ties to Crack Trade” on Democracy Now! The video includes
an extended clip from the 2012 documentary “Shadows of Liberty” that talks
about how freedom of the press in the United States is eroding under increasing
corporate control.
“CIA: America’s Secret Warriors.” (1997). Directed by Marc Levin. The series
included a brief history examining the allegations that the agency worked with
drug traffickers at the end of World War 2 in Sicily, the KMT in China, the
Hmong tribesmen using Air America during the Vietnam war, the various
anti-communist insurgents in Latin America and the Mujahideen in Afghanistan in
the late ’70s and ’80s.
Sources and Recommended
Reading
Blum, William and Peter
Scott. Killing Hope: U.S.
Military and CIA Interventions Since World War II. Common Courage Press
(July 1995).
Central Intelligence
Agency. Directorate of
Intelligence. “CIA Public Affairs and the Drug Conspiracy Story.” Managing a
Nightmare. “In the world of public relations, as in war avoiding a rout in the
face of hostile multitudes can be considered a success.” 2014-07-29. www.foia.cia.gov/…/DOC_0001372115.pdf
Cockburn, Alexander and
Jeffrey St. Clair. Whiteout: The CIA,
Drugs and the Press. Verso (November 17, 1999). “On March 16, 1998, the
CIA’s Inspector General, Fred Hitz, finally let the cat out of the bag in an
aside at a Congressional Hearing. Hitz told the US Reps that the CIA had
maintained relationships with companies and individuals the Agency knew to be
involved in the drug business. Even more astonishingly, Hitz revealed that back
in 1982 the CIA had requested and received from Reagan’s Justice Department
clearance not to report any knowledge it might have of drug-dealing by CIA
assets. “With these two admissions, Hitz definitively sank decades of CIA
denials, many of them under oath to Congress. Hitz’s admissions also made fools
of some of the most prominent names in US journalism, and vindicated
investigators andcritics of the Agency, ranging from Al McCoy to Senator John
Kerry.”
Lee, Martin A. and
Norman Solomon. Unreliable Sources:
A Guide to Detecting Bias in the News Media. 1st ed. 1990. LGLA (January
13, 2013).
Lippmann, Walter and
Charles Merz. “A Test of the News.” The
New Republic, August 1920. “Their study came out as a forty-two page
supplement to the New Republic in August 1920 and demonstrated that the
Times’ coverage was neither unbiased nor accurate. They concluded that the
paper’s news stories were not based on facts, but were “dominated by the hopes
of the men who composed the news organizations.” The paper cited events that
did not happen, atrocities that never took place, and reported no fewer than
ninety-one times that theBolshevik regime was on the verge of collapse. “The
news about Russia is a case of seeing not what was, but what men wished to
see,” Lippmann and Merz charged. ‘The chief censor and the chief propagandist
were hope and fear in the minds of reporters and editors.’ ”
Mackenzie, Angus. Secrets: The CIA’s War at Home.University of
California Press; New Ed edition (April 22, 1999).
Marcy, William L. The politics of cocaine: how U.S. policy has
created a thriving drug industry in Central and South America. Chicago
Review Press. (2010).
Mackenzie, Angus. Secrets: The CIA’s War at Home. University of California Press; New Ed edition
(April 22, 1999).
McCoy, Alfred W. The Politics of Heroin: CIA Complicity in the
Global Drug Trade. Chicago Review Press;
Revised edition (May 1, 2003). “The first book to prove CIA and U.S. government
complicity in global drug trafficking…” Amazon reviewer: “A historical study of
the opium and heroin trade and its political context, based on primary and
secondary sources, including interviews with some of the key players of the
developments in Indochina in the 1950s through 1970s.”
_______“The Sordid Contra-Cocaine Saga.”
ConsortiumNews, 2014-10-09. http://consortiumnews.com/2014/10/09/the-sordid-contra-cocaine-saga/
”If you ever wondered how the mainstream U.S. mediachanged from the hard-nosed
Watergate press of the 1970s into the brown-nose MSM that swallowed the Iraq
War lies, a key middle point was the Contra-cocaine scandal of the
1980s/1990s.”
_______ Lost History:
Contras, Cocaine, the Press & ‘Project Truth.’ Media Consortium; 1 edition (July 1, 1999).
Amazon reviewer: “This book is a real gem. It outlines a tale of both
corruption and ideological mendacity within the White House, and of ignorance
and unprofessionalism with the Directorate of Operations in the Central
Intelligence Agency….The editors of the history of the Department of State have
on several occasions complained, both publicly and privately, that an accurate
history of the foreign relations of the United States of America cannot be
written without more complete disclosure of our various covert operations.”
Pincus, Walter ”Inspector: CIA kept Ties With Alleged
Traffickers.” The Washington Post, 1998-03-17 A12.
Prouty, L. Fletcher (author). Jesse Ventura (foreword). The
Secret Team: The CIA and Its Allies in Control of the United States and the
World. Skyhorse Publishing; Second Edition edition (April 1, 2011). Prouty
is controversial but it is a fact that he “was a retired colonel of the U.S.
Air Force, served as the chief of special operations for the Joint Chiefs of
Staff during the Kennedy years, and was directly in charge of the global system
designed to provide military support for the clandestine activities of the
CIA.” One Amazon reviewer writes: “This is an extremely important book. The
proof of it is that even the official copy in the Library of Congress
disappeared (!). Moreover, even after his death, the author continues to be the
object of a smear campaign.”
Risen, James. Pay Any Price: Greed, Power, and Endless
War. War corrupts. Endless war corrupts absolutely. Houghton Mifflin
Harcourt (October 14, 2014).
______State of War: The
Secret History of the CIA and the Bush Administration. Free Press; First Edition edition (January 5,
2006)
Schou, Nick. Kill the
Messenger (Movie Tie-In Edition): How the CIA’s Crack-Cocaine Controversy
Destroyed Journalist Gary Webb. Nation Books; Revised Edition edition
(September 9, 2014).
Scott, Peter Dale. American War Machine: Deep Politics, the CIA
Global Drug Connection, and the Road to Afghanistan (War and Peace
Library). Rowman & Littlefield Publishers; 1St Edition edition (November
16, 2010).
Solomon, Norman. War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep
Spinning Us to Death. Wiley
(June 1, 2006).
Spartacus Educational. “Walter Pincus.” http://spartacus-educational.com/MDpincus.htm
”Walter Pincus also led the attack on Gary Webb when he published his series of
articles on CIA involvement with the Contras and the drug industry. After Dark Alliance was
published Pincus wrote: “‘Washington Post investigation into Ross, Blandon,
Meneses, and the U.S. cocaine market in the 1980s found the available
information does not support the conclusion that the CIA-backed contras – or
Nicaraguans in general – played a major role in the emergence of crack as
anarcotic in widespread use across the United States. ”The Washington Post
refused to publish Webb’s letters when he attempted to defend his views on the
CIA. This included information that Pincus had been recruited by the CIA when
he was at Yale University in order to spy on student
groups at several international youth conferences in the 1950s. Later, Geneva
Overholser, the Washington Post ombudsman, criticized Pincus and other
reporters working for the newspaper: ‘A principal responsibility of the press
is to protect the people from government excesses. The Washington Post (among
others) showed more energy for protecting the CIA from someone else’s
journalistic excesses.’ ”When Gary Webb committed suicide, French
journalist, Paul Moreira, made
a television documentary for France’s Canal Plus. He interviewed Pincus and asked
him why in October, 1998, he had not reported on the CIA’sinspector general
report admitting the agency worked with drug dealers throughout the 1980s.
Pincus was unable to explain why he and other mainstream journalists completely
ignored this report that helped to support Webb’s case against the CIA.”
Webb, Gary. Dark Alliance: Movie Tie-In Edition: The
CIA, the Contras, and the Cocaine Explosion. Seven Stories Press; Reprint
edition (September 30, 2014). 1st ed. June 1999.
0 comments:
Post a Comment